Sitting Out the Surf: How Turnout, Not Swing, Built the Blue Wave
Washington, D.C., November 16, 2026: New analysis by J.L. Partners, based on a 1,000 sample Election Day poll and analysis of 30,000+ interviews conducted during the campaign, has found that around 70% of the Democrat surge in last week’s midterms was due to turnout effects rather than voters switching sides.
The postmortem report, Sitting out the Surf: How Turnout, Not Swing, Built the Blue Wave, has far-reaching consequences for how lawmakers and campaigns react to the election results. The report’s architects said that without a single vote switching, the GOP would have lost the Senate and the House, and that those eager to ditch ‘MAGA politics’ for traditional Republicanism risk over-reacting to the results.
The analysis found that, of the 15-point swing that took place in 2026 (from R+2 in 2024 to D+13 in 2026), 10 of those points can be accounted for by turnout, 5 by switching; meaning turnout accounted for around 67% of the swing.
Overall, more than one in three Trump 2024 voters (35%) did not vote in November 2026, compared with 22% of Harris 2024 voters. Trump’s non-graduate voters, rural voters, and retirees stayed at home in large numbers, dooming the Republican majority before any switching took place:
Almost half (46%) of voters without college education who voted Trump in 2024 did not vote in 2026
39% of rural voters who voted Trump in 2024 did not vote in 2026
44% of over-65s who voted Trump in 2024 did not vote in 2026
This is not to say those who switched are unimportant to strategists. Just under one in ten Trump voters (8%) switched to Democrat candidates. These voters were disproportionately more likely to be younger voters (especially Gen Z), men, non-white voters, and to live in Urban areas. In troubling signs for Republicans hoping the Democratic Party lurches left, these voters have a net positive view of DSA candidates, with 44% approving of the Democratic Socialists of America movement and only 27% disapproving.
The report also found:
Democrats won by dominating among those who strongly disapprove of Trump, by 90% to 6% for Republicans
Half of those who voted Democrat (48%) say their vote was a vote against Donald Trump rather than for the Democratic Party’s platform
Half of switchers from Trump to Democrats in 2026 (50%) say they still have a favorable view of the Republican Party, suggesting they could be won back
The cost of living and the economy dominated, with corruption as the third most-cited reason for why people voted the way they did. In every group, "cost of living (including gas prices)" and "the economy" were the top two issues, with a third (33%) of 2026 voters picking one of them. Among 2026 voters, no other issue got more than 9%
Only 16% of those who voted Democrat in 2026 want the top priority to be impeachment of President Trump
Despite the Blue Wave, only 30% of registered voters say the Democratic Party has a candidate that is ready to be President in 2028
Mark Kelly is the candidate that performs best with 2026 voters - and those that defected from Trump to the Democrats
Carson Bradley, author of the report, said:
“The Democrats got their voters to the polls this year. Many of Trump’s 2024 voters who consider themselves Independents sat this one out, appearing unmotivated to follow the President’s call to back Republican candidates. Those who did switch their vote between the last two cycles are broadly favorable to both parties, meaning they will be up for grabs in 2028.”
James Johnson, Founding Director of J.L. Partners, said:
“Even without a single voter switching, the GOP would have lost the Senate and House. That is how important turnout was at this election. Looking at this report I am taking away from it that the GOP should not throw the MAGA baby out with the bathwater just yet - if Republicans can energize their 2024 vote in 2028, then they may yet have a shot at winning again. It is also notable that Trump defectors are not looking for re-heated ‘traditional Republicanism’: they like the DSA, and are made up of the nonwhite, younger men that Trump won over for the first time in 2024.”
Download links
Coverage in the New York Post: Link
Read the full report: Link
Download the data tables: Link
Method
J.L. Partners polled a representative sample of 1,000 registered voters online across the United States on Election Day. Quotas kept the sample representative on the following: General and primary election participation, gender, age, race, education, region, party and 2024 presidential vote. The sample was weighted back to the registered voter population on the following: Gender, age, race, education, region, party, 2024 presidential vote and general election participation. 2026 voters (n = 870, voted or will vote on Election Day) have a separate weight to a D+13 House vote.
Margin of error: 3.1% (registered voters), 3.3% (2026 voters), 10.5% (Trump defectors, n = 87).
Findings were verified by analysis of over 30,000 interviews that took place during the campaign using a mix of SMS-to-web, online panel, and live calls to landline and to cell.
